Bombay Hospital Journal ContentsHomeArchivesSearchBooksFeedback

COST EFFECTIVENESS/YIELD/MEDICAL ECONOMICS

Simple Nondrug Management of Non-Radiating Neck Pain
OP Kapoor

All of you must be quite aware that the incidence of cervical spondylosis is highest in the third and fourth decades of life (as compared to lumbar spondylosis which occurs in older people). The diagnosis in such patients should be made by neck pain, which radiates along the root to the arm, depending on which root is pressed.

However, here I am discussing neck pains, which are approximately of less than ten days duration and are often due to bad posture of neck during sleep or a bad pillow. Such pains often respond to hot or cold compresses to the neck application of some liniment or ointment at night to the neck, or change of pillow. Sometimes, one can advise a cervical collar. There is no sense in continuing to prescribe painkillers in all the above cases.

DIAGNOSIS OF STROKE ON NEUROIMAGING

‘Scan all immediately’ strategy improves outcomes and reduces costs.

In an NHS health technology assessment study, on average each hospital admission for stroke cost about 11,000 ($19 800; € 16,000). A few patients per day per hospital quickly accumulate high costs. A computed tomography scan costs between £ 44 and £ 130. The imaging strategy for computed tomography producing the highest number of quality adjusted life years at the lowest cost was ‘scan all immediately’. Even a marginal shift from dependent to independent survival after stroke through correct early diagnosis with computed tomography and appropriate treatment (aspirin for most patients with ischaemic stroke and its avoidance in intracerebral haemorrhage) is the most cost effective strategy, despite the marginal benefits of treatment.

JM Wardlaw, AJ Farrall, BMJ, 2004; 328 : 655-56.




Ex. Hon. Physician, Jaslok Hospital and Bombay Hospital, Mumbai, Ex. Hon. Prof. of Medicine, Grant Medical College and JJ Hospital, Mumbai 400 008.


To Section TOC
Sponsor-Dr.Reddy's Lab